CConsolidation Debt

Compare options

HELOC vs. second mortgage vs. refinance

Three ways to consolidate debt with home equity in Toronto. Each has real trade-offs. Here's how they compare.

RefinanceHELOCSecond mortgage
What it isReplace your first mortgage with a new, larger oneRevolving line of credit secured by your homeSeparate lump-sum loan registered behind your first mortgage
Existing mortgagePaid out and replacedUsually stays in placeStays in place
Typical rate levelGenerally lowest of the threeUsually variable, above prime-based mortgage ratesGenerally higher, especially with private lenders
PaymentsFixed blended principal + interestOften interest-only minimum; flexibleFixed payments; often interest-only with private lenders
TermStandard mortgage terms (e.g. 1–5 years)Open-ended while the line is activeOften short terms (e.g. 1–2 years) with private lenders
Penalty riskMay trigger a penalty to break your current mortgageNo penalty on the first mortgageNo penalty on the first mortgage
QualificationFull income, credit and stress-test reviewStrong credit and income typically requiredMore flexible; equity can weigh more heavily
Best suited toLarger consolidations near renewal or with low penaltiesDisciplined borrowers wanting flexibilityWhen breaking the first mortgage is costly or bank qualification is difficult

General comparison only. Actual rates, terms and fees vary by lender and borrower and are set after underwriting.

Refinancing to consolidate debt

A refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a new one for a higher amount, and the difference pays off your other debts. Because it's a first mortgage, it usually carries the lowest rate. The main thing to check is your prepayment penalty. If you're mid-term on a fixed rate, the penalty can be significant. Refinancing at or near renewal is often the most cost-effective timing.

HELOC debt consolidation

A home equity line of credit lets you borrow against your equity as needed. Paying off cards with a HELOC can lower interest costs, but interest-only minimum payments mean the balance doesn't shrink unless you pay more. A HELOC works best for people who are confident they won't re-borrow.

Second mortgage debt consolidation in Toronto

A second mortgage is a separate loan behind your first, so your existing rate and term stay untouched. It can be helpful when breaking your first mortgage would be expensive or when bank qualification is a challenge. Rates and fees are typically higher, and private second mortgages are often short-term, so it's important to have a clear plan for what happens at the end of the term.

How to choose

Talk it through, no pressure.

A free, confidential conversation about your debts and your home equity. You decide what happens next.